Well, it’s done. Prairie and I just got back from seeing The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King at the Cinerama.
I read something earlier this week on the ‘net. Unfortunately, I can’t remember where, so I can’t give attribution — but it’s a statement that I can now say quite safely that I wholeheartedly agree with. Until this year, had someone mentioned The Trilogy in conversation so that you could hear the capital ‘t’s, it would have been fairly understood that they most likely were talking about Star Wars.
Not anymore. LotR:TRotK caps off the new reigning champion of popular cinematic trilogys in grand style.
Prairie and I had tickets to the 7:45pm showing, but we knew that this being opening weekend we’d want to get there fairly early to ensure good seats. So, after an early bed last night and a good night’s sleep, we packed up our supplies (books for each of us, an umbrella, and two collapsible chairs from the trunk of her car), we headed down to the Cinerama at 4pm. We weren’t sure at first whether that might have been a bit too early, but as it turns out, our instincts were right on the money, as we ended up about 15 people back from the front of the line (in fact, we realized that we’d ended up waiting at almost exactly the same spot for all three weeks of our LotR experience), and it wasn’t more than about five minutes before more people showed up and took the spots right behind us.
Luckily enough, it turned out to be a nicely mild evening, without the wind and drizzling rain of last weekend. We’d each bundled up for the wait, and ended up spending a very pleasant three hours kicked back in our spot, chatting, reading, and watching the line grow behind us as more and more people appeared. About ten minutes before the doors opened I took a few minutes to stretch my legs and went off to find the end of the line…which had wrapped down from the Cinerama to the corner, around the corner, and then halfway again down the length of the block. We were quite happy we decided to come out as early as we did!
About the only downside was that when we arrived, there was one guy just ahead of us in line — but by the time the doors were about to open, he’d been joined by five of his friends (and this had also happened with a few other people ahead of us in line, and just behind us as well). I can certainly understand holding a spot in line for one friend, but it’s nothing but annoying when someone holds a spot at the beginning of the line for groups of people, who can then show up not more than ten minutes before the doors open and slide into line in front of people who’d been waiting there for hours. Very rude, and quite aggravating — luckily for them, I didn’t think my umbrella would stand up to smacking all six of them around, so I kept my peace.
Still, once the doors opened and the line surged forward, we made our way in and managed to snag good seats yet again — dead center, six rows back on the lower level (just one row closer to the screen than last week, and two rows closer than we were for Fellowship — thank goodness it’s only a trilogy!). After that, it was just a matter of waiting for everyone to fill in and find their seats, until eventually, the lights went down, and applause and cheers filled the room.
We were treated to three trailers before the show started. The first was for Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, which got applause and cheers from the audience. Next up was a trailer for The Mask is Back, which had the audience in dumbfounded silence until the end, when the auditorium was filled with a resounding chorus of boos and catcalls (which did something to restore some of my faith in the intelligence of the moviegoing public — or at least that section of the moviegoing public crazy enough to stand in line for LotR:TRotK on its first weekend). Last up was a trailer for The Butterfly Effect, which didn’t get much of a reaction at all (the trailers don’t impress me much, but I am interested in the premise of the film, so we’ll see how that goes once it opens).
Finally, the lights went down all the way, and the movie began… Rather than jumping straight into the action as was done with LotR:TTT, LotR:TRotK starts off with a look back long before the events of the trilogy, fleshing out Gollum’s background and showing the discovery of the Ring and the tragic events surrounding Smeagol’s acquisition of his “birthday present” from his brother Deagol. A marvelously creepy sequence shows us Smeagol’s deterioration into Gollum under the influence of the Ring, until we finally cut forward to hear Gollum muttering to himself as Sam and Frodo rest on their journey into Mordor.
(Note: much of the following text is “spoiler” information, which I’ve hidden for the time being — just swipe the blank areas of the text with your cursor if you’ve already seen the film….)
This is by far the most intense of the three films, moving back and forth among multiple storylines, hardships, moments of despair, and sudden triumphs. As jaw-dropping as the assault on Helms Deep was in LotR:TTT, the assault on Minis Tirith puts it to shame. There were so many wonderful (and wonderfully horrible) moments in the battles, from the Orc commander’s call to “release the prisoners” (at which point the severed heads of fallen Gondorian soldiers were lobbed into Minas Tirith), to the appearance of the giant war-Olifaunts, to Eowyn’s stand against the Nazgul king — “I am no man!” — (which got one of the loudest cheers from the audience) that I’m going to have to see it at least once more in the theaters just to start to take it all in. One amusing side-note about the Orc commander, though — I’d always wondered just what happened to Sloth after Goonies ended…and now I know!
Shelob was everything I’d been hoping she’d be, marvelously frightening and menacing. Her sudden appearance from the hole in the cave wall just when you think that Frodo made it through her lair safely got a wonderful gasp, and the scene where she hovers over Frodo was perfectly done! Everyone in the audience was on the edge of their seat, with nervous laughter filling the room from the tension of the moment…and when she finally strikes, everyone gasped and laughed with the sudden release of that tension — until the sudden realization hit that Frodo had been stung, when the entire auditorium fell dead silent.
I loved, loved, loved the look of the army of the dead that Aragorn confronts.
The interaction among Gollum, Frodo and Sam, as Gollum uses the effects of the ring to aid him in his own treachery was handled perfectly, so much so that it almost hurt to watch as his efforts took hold.
All in all, a truly masterful achievement. But, as the saying goes, all good things must come to an end, and — save looking forward to the release of the Extended Edition on DVD next November — the journey is finally finished. The credits rolled, the lights came up, and we left the theater, at first with little more than “Oh, wow,” on our lips. Next out from Prairie was, “I want to go back to stand in line and see it again!” I can’t really argue with that!
Congratulations, Peter Jackson (and everyone else involved) — you’ve filmed what was commonly held to be an unfilmable work. Now, would someone please release the rights so that he can do The Hobbit?!? I want to see Smaug on screen!
I totally agree with your comment about the orc commander! too funny. :) did you look at his left shoulder (on your right) – ugh. and double gross. the orc commander was a strong character though, for as little time as he got on the screen.
The Olifaunts were the absolute best. I swear – beginning when the riders of Rohan swept the field, I was on the edge of my seat, nearly quaking with the adrenaline of it all. I think I cried when Gandalf was talking to Pippin as they holed up in the hallway behind the door. I also cheered for Eowyn, which was a little out of place since Fairbanksans aren’t so vocal in the theater.
I went again on Saturday with Denton and watched for more of the symbolism, which I found in some interesting places. For example, when Faramir goes back, the last scene with Denethor eating gave much indication of the question of the outcome. God, I hate being so cryptic.
My complaints about the movie were – what happened to Saruman? He just kind of disappeared. Apparently there will be more in the DVD release that wasn’t included in the theater. The army of the dead looked a little Pirates of the Carribean for me – but they were good, especially when they fought the Olifaunt in the background. I hope they show more of the ending battle scenes on the DVD.
I agree, this is the new Trilogy. I was thinking myself that this was the Star Wars of our generation. I can’t remember being so excited about a movie, ever.
What I really would like is to see this movie at the IMAX. The cinematography is excellent, and very effective when you are up close like I was at the first showing.
Hrm — nope, or at least not that I’m remembering right offhand. I’m sure I’ll be seeing the movie again at least once in the theater, though, so I’ll be sure to take another look next time.
Yeah, there’s been a fair amount of controversy about that editing choice (and apparently Christopher Lee was none to happy about it). Peter Jackson has said that it was just one of the many difficult editing decisions that had to be made:
It’s a shame that things worked out that way, but I can certainly see it being tricky to fit in smoothly, especially with the amount of story that had to be worked into RotK. On the one hand, it would be “just seven more minutes” at the beginning of the film — on the other hand, when the movie ended up at 3:20, every minute counts!
I dunno — I can certainly see the comparison, but I thought the look was great (besides, how many ways can you make an “army of the dead” look creepy without resembling other animated-skeletal-corpses?). It looked to me almost like a living X-ray, where you could see both the skeleton and the moving tissues at the same time, where the Pirates when revealed in moonlight were essentially just walking skeletons. Both effects were well done, but I think it’s more just an accident of timing that Pirates was released recently enough for comparisons to be made (why not compare both RotK and Pirates to Harryhausen’s work in Jason and the Argonauts, for example?).
Oh, ugh…count me out on that one! After seeing Matrix: Reloaded at the Seattle Center’s IMAX, I’m not a huge fan of “normal” films on the IMAX screen — it’s just too much. The screen was so huge, and the action in the movie was so fast that it was incredibly difficult to track on what was happening. I’d much rather be able to concentrate on what’s happening than have to constantly whip my head back and forth trying to figure out where on this six-story high screen I should be focusing!
it was a little sickening, wasn’t it? i liked it. :)
i guess maybe it’s like rollercoasters – you like them or you don’t. i’ve never been on a rollercoaster, but i actually liked the semi-sick feeling i got from the full visual experience at the imax. it felt like i imagine a rollercoaster would feel – complete immersion.
i would say that it probably worked better that i had already seen ‘reloaded’ once – i would definitely want to see RotK in a regular theater first. then, bring on the six-story screen and throw me in front of it!